
The age-old saying is true even so in the workplace: age is but a number. It should not define how employers decide your application or employment status. In fact, there is a federal law that protects employees age 40 and up from being discriminated against based on their age.
Age discrimination comes in many forms. The most common situations are overlooked promotions, termination, harassment, and unfair performance reviews. If you think you’ve been treated negatively because of your age, you can reach out to experienced age discrimination attorneys to start exploring your options.
Any trusted attorney for age discrimination will help you investigate your claim further, gather important evidence, and hold your employer accountable. Read on to learn what you and your lawyer’s possible stance can be below.
Is age discrimination happening in your workplace?
Age discrimination is simply the unjust treatment of employees based on their age. This involves different workplace processes including hiring, promotion, compensation, and privileges.
The Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967 protects employees aged 40 years old and higher from these unfair employment treatments. Additionally, this only applies to employers with 20 or more employees.
The ADEA was actually amended in 1990 to further improve the protections of workers aged 40 and older. Called the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act (OWBPA), this amendment makes sure every employee gets equal access to benefits regardless of their age.
OWBPA also makes sure that employees over 40 get fair treatment in terms of layoffs, retirements, and voluntary separation. For example, if a company is downsizing, employers should make sure that their workers aged 40 or older are not terminated simply because of their age.
Under the OWBPA, employees over 40 are entitled to being offered early retirement plans, exit incentives, severance pay, and even health benefit extensions if they are voluntarily or involuntarily terminated.
Examples of age discrimination in the workplace
There are various situations when age discrimination happens in the workplace. Knowing and understanding these situations can help you determine if your employer is committing violations against ADEA (Age Discrimination in Employment Act).
Here are the common scenarios where age discrimination happens at work:
Hiring discrimination
This mainly involves applicants being discriminated against because of their age (being 40 years old or older). For instance, if a specific job posting specifically requests “young” workers or employers generally preferring younger applicants despite older applicants showing similar or even better work experience.
Another example would be biased interviews, including asking about retirement plans or your age. At the same time, employers dismissing older employees as overqualified can be seen as a form of hiring discrimination as well.
Discriminatory layoffs or termination
Targeted reductions in the workplace is the most common example in terms of discriminatory layoffs. If you have been terminated, along with other employees who are mostly over 40, you might have an age discrimination claim. This is most especially if the remaining employees are younger, but evidently less experienced in the department.
Reorganization tactics can also be a form of age discrimination that employees should actively watch out for. Completely removing senior positions and hiring employees with less or even no experience so the employer could offer a lower paygrade discriminates against older employees.
Finally, it’s a form of age discrimination when employers terminate older employees shortly before retirement eligibility.
Promotion and career advancement bias
One of the most common examples is when younger employees are promoted over more qualified older employees. At the same time, Performance Improvement Plans (PIP) can be used against older employees. For example, if a senior employee (40 years old or older) received subjective and negative performance reviews seemingly out of nowhere, despite having consistently positive reviews previously, it’s an age-discriminatory situation.
This lessens the opportunity for older employees to advance their careers in the company from these fabricated negative PIPs. If this is the case with you, it’s important to collect the performance reviews to have a clear comparison. Sudden negative reviews justify termination or being rejected for promotions.
Training opportunities being withheld from older employees can also be seen as one of the signs of age discrimination. Your employer should give unbiased and equal chances in the workplace for your career development, regardless of your age.
Harassment and workplace bias
Age-related jokes and name-calling in the workplace are also considered age discrimination. While your employer or colleagues might argue that these are harmless, these still count as ageism issues. For instance, telling an employee that they are “too old” for their work is still misconduct and discrimination.
Aside from hostile comments or insults, few other biases come in the form of unequal pay or benefits, exclusion, aggressive management, or pressure to retire. Exclusion means not being in work meetings, social activities, or other work-related events. Aggressive management happens when employers increase an employee’s workload, or setting them to fail simply because of their age.
How an age discrimination attorney evaluates a case
Age discrimination lawyers have to evaluate your claim first. There are three key elements that your attorney would initially analyze:
- The employee is 40 years old or older
- The employee has experienced discrimination in the workplace
- The evidence suggests that the employee’s age is the motivating factor for the said discrimination
For this initial legal evaluation process, an age discrimination attorney will review your personnel files, disciplinary records, witness statements, and your job’s company policies. As with any potential discrimination claim, employees should collect as much significant evidence as they can.
A guide to gathering evidence to prove age discrimination
The evidence you submit should be able to support your claim that your employer has terminated or treated you unfairly at work due to your age being 40 years or older. Additionally, this evidence will have to shift the burden of proof to the employer. In order to do that, your evidence should be substantial otherwise your claim will be dismissed.
There are two main types of evidence in age discrimination claims:
- Direct evidence: This includes documentation you’ve gathered like emails referencing your age in the workplace and written policies or statements that target workers aged 40 and up.
- Circumstantial evidence: These are as significant as direct evidence, but they are often hard to obtain. For instance, it would be difficult to prove that younger employees are treated better in your workplace, or there has indeed been a pattern of layoffs that are targeted towards older employees. At the same time, sudden negative performance reviews do not directly prove that this is because your employer is discriminating against your age.
What are the legal strategies attorneys use to challenge employers?
A few common employer defenses against workplace age discrimination claims are poor performance, restructuring, and business necessity. The age discrimination attorney and the employee should prove that age is indeed the determining reason behind the employer’s action, not just one of several factors.
Attorneys challenge employer defenses by showing inconsistencies, sudden disciplinary actions, and replacement by younger employees.
Furthermore, company policies should not disproportionately affect older workers even if it appears neutral or without intent to discriminate. The Smith v. City of Jackson case’s ruling established that ADEA permits “disparate impact” claims.
Regarding the case, Azel Smith and a group of police officers sued Jackson City in Mississippi because the city police department gave out higher percentage raises to younger officers.
While the court did establish that older workers can sue their employers from company policies that unintentionally disadvantage them because of their age, the court also ruled that there are other reasonable factors behind the pay raise. Specifically, Jackson City’s plan to match salaries to the regional average.
How to file an age discrimination claim
There are a few important steps you need to do first before filing an age discrimination lawsuit. The first thing you need to do is to file a charge with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) within 180 days of the age discrimination situation that allegedly happened in the workplace.
You can file online through the EEOC Public Portal or in-person, at the EEOC public office. In Alabama, this can be done at the Birmingham District Office.
After filing your EEOC charge, the EEOC will investigate or mediate your claim. The possible outcomes would be mediation settlement, dismissal, or a right-to-sue letter. If you’ve received a right-to-sue letter, you can then file a lawsuit in federal court.
What happens during an age discrimination lawsuit
If your case does proceed to a lawsuit, the first stage would be the discovery phase. During this time, your age discrimination attorney and your employer’s attorney would both gather evidence including HR records, emails, work communications, and deposition testimonies.
After evidence gathering, negotiations would take place and most often than not, settlement. If both parties can’t agree to a settlement, the case proceeds to court.
Remedies available in age discrimination cases
If your age discrimination lawsuit is successful, potential remedies include back pay, lost benefits, reinstatement, attorney fees, and liquidated damages for willful violations.
Other remedies include voluntary settlements with the help of the EEOC and formal apologies. Company policies can also undergo revisions to make sure no future age discrimination happens to older employees.
How age discrimination attorneys help protect workers’ rights
Attorneys play a role in investigating your claim, gathering evidence, and giving legal advice or options. If you do push through your lawsuit, age discrimination attorneys help negotiate settlements or litigate cases in court.
Employment laws like the ADEA exist to protect employees from unjust workplace treatment based on their age. In a way, age discrimination attorneys help employees as well, but only if they raise the issue and file a claim.
If you’re seeking legal advice about your worker rights, you can contact lawyers like Kira Fonteneau to help you get started immediately.