Judge and employment prosecutor looking at employment discrimination attorney The most common employer defenses that employment discrimination lawyers present in court. Kira Fonteneau Employment Lawyer

As an employee who steps into the court in a discrimination lawsuit, it’s critical to know and understand the defense of employers for the case. This way, you and your lawyer have equal expectations of how the lawsuit will unfold.

First and foremost, you should know that employers will almost always deny the discrimination that you or someone you know has allegedly experienced in the workplace. And in most discrimination cases, it depends on the reason the employer gives in court. With that, let’s take a look at the most common defenses employers raise. 

The legal framework behind discrimination claims

You should know that Alabama relies on federal law for most discrimination claims. There are a few federal anti-discrimination laws that protect employees in the workplace. They are:

  • Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964: This federal law protects workers from any type of discrimination in the workplace. At the same time, it also prohibits employers from retaliating when a discriminatory intent has been reported to authorities.
  • ADEA (Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967): This federal law protects workers and applicants who are at least 40 years old against age discrimination and unequal treatment in the workplace.
  • ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act): This helps protect individuals with disabilities to find and keep employment, as well as be provided with reasonable accommodations for them to perform their roles and responsibilities in the workplace.
  • Pregnancy discrimination: Under the Pregnancy Discrimination Act and Title VII, applicants or employees should not be given unfavorable treatment due to pregnancy, childbirth, or other related medical conditions.

What is the burden-shifting framework?

In discrimination cases, the plaintiff (or the allegedly discriminated employee) is the one responsible for providing evidence firsthand. The burden of proof then shifts to the defendant (the employer) to give a non-discriminatory reason for their actions. 

Under the McDonnell Douglas burden-shifting framework, this is a three-step process:

  1. The employee establishes a prima facie case – Prima facie is a Latin term that means “at first sight”. In discrimination cases, the employee should provide sufficient and initial evidence that can fully support their discrimination claims. 

The key aspect of this first step is that the evidence should be substantial enough so the judges won’t dismiss the case. This first step prevents frivolous lawsuits.

  1. Employer should give a legitimate, non-discriminatory reason – The burden of showing proof now falls to the employer. They should provide reasons for their action.
  2. Employee must prove their pretext – Pretext, in this case, should show that the employer has inconsistent explanations, shifting stories, and even timing issues.

The most common employer defenses in discrimination cases

As mentioned, it’s vital for you as the employer in a discrimination case to know what the usual defenses employers submit to the court. This can help you plan what you’ll be showing or collecting as your initial evidence. 

1. The “legitimate, non-discriminatory reason”

This is the most used defense by employers, and it has different forms. The key point that employment discrimination lawyers will also explain to you is that it doesn’t matter if the employer’s decision is fair or not. What the court will consider is whether the action was discriminatory or not. There are a few legal reasons can be submitted by your employer, such as:

  • Negative performance evaluations
  • Company policy violations
  • Attendance issues
  • Company restructuring
  • Economic layoffs

In terms of performance evaluations, attendance, and policy violations, you should be ready for documentation that these are not, in fact, legal reasons for your claim. Aside from documentation, you should also prepare timing and performance history for your lawsuit. 

Attorneys for employment discrimination analyze these factors so it’s very important for you to carefully organize and compile your evidence beforehand.

2. Bona Fide Occupational Qualification (BFOQ)

The BFOQ is considered as an exception in discrimination cases that allows employers to limit a specific role to applicants with a specific characteristic. This set and protected characteristic, however, needs to be directly relevant to the job’s main role and responsibility.

Some legal examples of legal workplace exceptions are:

  • A theology school requiring teachers to be of the same faith
  • Mandatory age retirement requirement for roles with critical safety risks
  • Same-sex privacy and personal care staff for restrooms or locker rooms

In some instances, you can ask this during a discrimination lawyers free consultation session to get a better insight regarding your specific situation. This is because you might be facing an invalid BFOQ. For example, refusing to hire or keep you at work due to gender-based stereotypes and customer preference are not legal BFOQs. 

3. Business necessity

This is the legal justification of employers for specific job roles that may negatively affect a protected group. This is unintentional in nature and for employers to successfully prove this, they should be able to provide job-related proof that the policy is directly related to a role’s specific skills. The employer should prove that there are no alternative policies available in their existing business model.

Here are a few examples:

  • Educational qualifications
  • Testing standards
  • Background checks

While this applies to most discrimination claims, this is most important in cases involving racial discrimination. You can ask racial discrimination attorneys to consider looking at your case with this specific angle.

4. Same-actor inference

This is a defense wherein if the same manager or supervisor hired and fired the same employee within a short period of time, then it’s not likely because of discrimination. The logic behind this is that there is an unlikely bias with this type of situation.

Some courts actually use this to consider whether they should dismiss a discrimination claim or not. The first question that the court considers, and what may be asked to you by employment discrimination lawyers is, “What has changed?”. 

For instance, if an employee has been hired and fired by the same manager within 5 months, was the reason because she became pregnant within that time period? This goes the same with long-time employees. The legal reason for firing would be a steady decline of performance, and if the employer can’t prove this, it might really be a plausible discrimination case.

5. After-acquired evidence

If the reason for dismissal is really discriminatory, but the employer found a legal employee misconduct after terminating the employee, it does not fully absolve the employer of liability. Instead, the damages usually lessens and will be limited by the court.

The employer must also prove that the discovered misconduct does not warrant dismissal. For example, if an employee has been fired because of age discrimination, and the employer has found evidence of theft right after, the employer will not completely evade the discrimination claim.

6. Procedural and technical defenses

This type of defense focuses on deadlines and filings. If you’re an Alabama employee with a discrimination claim, this is highly important for you to take note of. 

In Alabama, if you fail to submit your EEOC Charge within 180 days, the employer might utilize this defense against you. Don’t forget to take note of other filing deadlines as well with your discrimination lawyer.

7. Strong documentation and internal policies

With discrimination cases, documentation is extremely important. Make sure you have records of your job contract, your company’s handbook and anti-discrimination policies, training records, performance evaluations, and even HR investigations relevant to your case. 

Paper trails prior, during, and after your employment can be evaluated by the court. Documentation and policies usually record consistency and if there has been an employee misconduct indeed, paper trails will prove them.

Alabama-specific considerations for discrimination cases

Alabama is one of most US states that follow at-will employment. This means that employers can fire employees for any legal reason or no reason at all. Employees are also allowed to submit their resignation to their employer at any time. 

However, the exceptions are illegal reasons for termination, which includes various types of discrimination and employer retaliation, among other reasons.

How do employer defenses affect discrimination claims?

Defenses vary depending on the type of discrimination claim. For instance, pregnancy discrimination lawyers might give different advice than racial discrimination attorneys.

Here are the different types of discrimination claims:

Pregnancy discrimination claims

For this type of claim, employer defenses would focus on proving that the firing is unrelated to pregnancy. The employer would focus more on the employee’s poor performance or use the same-actor inference.

Some of the popular counters are comparator evidence showing that there has been unequal treatment in the workplace and establishing a before/after timeline regarding the pregnancy.

Racial discrimination claims

Consider talking to racial discrimination attorneys regarding a possible statistical disparity of racial groups in the workplace. Additionally, you can also talk about the disparate discipline that employees might experience. 

You can compare your treatment of your employer to other employees that are not of the same race. And as always, remember to document as much unequal treatment you’ve experienced as possible.

Age discrimination claims

The usual language or word choices like “restructuring”, “energy”, and “culture fit” might come up more than usual when age discrimination happens in the workplace. When you’re consulting with an age discrimination attorney, be sure to raise these points, since these are early signs of a solid claim.

Why understanding employer defenses is important to winning your claim

Simply put, knowing your employer’s possible defenses can help you prepare ahead. Remember, the main point in any workplace discrimination claim is to prove that the reason given by the employer is not the true reason why you’ve been terminated. 
Employment discrimination lawyers like Kira Fonteneau evaluate documentation, timeline, performance reviews, witness statements, and comparator data. Your part is to gather as much relevant evidence for your discrimination claim. If you already have enough evidence, it’s time to reach out to an employment discrimination lawyer to give you legal counsel.

Scroll to Top